If You Support This Post, Boo It!

Post image for If You Support This Post, Boo It!

by SpeakoftheDevs on March 23, 2010

email

It’s that time of year again! The time of year when you have a pretty good idea of whether or not your team will make the playoffs.

The fascinating part about this time of year is the reaction you’ll get from some of the fans of the teams that are out of the playoff race, and sometimes, fans of teams fighting for a spot or a team that’s hanging on to the seventh or eighth seed.

Some fans reaction to the way their team is playing at this time of year is…to boo the team!

Pardon me if I’m missing the point, but what exactly do the fans that are booing their team hope to accomplish by doing this? Do they think the players on the ice will hear this and refuse to cash their five-digit paycheck for the week? Sure, that sounds like it would be the ideal result, but it ain’t happenin’.

These fans will go out and spend $200+ on a jersey to show “support” for their team. They will spend that same amount on a ticket and food/drinks at a game, to show their “support” in person. When they can’t make the game, they will sit home on their couch for three hours and “support” their team. If the team doesn’t play well, they boo.

Are you sure you want to do this?

Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for voicing your displeasure with the way your team is playing, when it’s warranted. I’ve been very frustrated, at times, with the way my team has played, especially on the power-play. Have I ever booed? Never. I’ve yelled, used some saucy language (shocking, I know), and sometimes gone to extremes and stormed off to grab another adult beverage…while play is still going on! But I’ve never booed.

I’ve been a fan of my team for a long time. It’s my team. If I’m at a game and a hear another so-called “supporter” of my team booing them, I take it personally. They are not there to support, they’re there to be entertained, and the team is not doing their job, according to this brand of fan.

The fans who boo will give you a list of reasons why it’s okay to boo the team:

  • I pay good money to watch these games;
  • The team is showing no heart;
  • These players are making millions of dollars;
  • I have a right to boo if I don’t like what I’m seeing;
  • It’s frustrating and they need to know how I feel

There are others, but no matter what I list, they’re all dumb reasons.

The team, and individual players, don’t owe you anything. There is no guarantee anywhere that says the team will win, or even play well, for you. You choose to watch these games, either at home or in person. Perhaps you should start booing yourself for making poor decisions or choosing a bad team to “support.”

You chose to buy that jersey. You chose to watch the game. You continue to be a fan of this team. Do you really think booing is going to make things better?

Perhaps a better strategy would be actually not watch the game. Not buy team merchandise. Not watch the games. Maybe then the team, and players, would truly get the point…that you’re not happy with their play.

I know that sounds pretty drastic, but maybe it would work better than booing a product that you choose to support.

Or maybe it’s me? Maybe the people that boo their team also boo other things, like:

  • They boo their wife, as she’s giving birth, for not pushing harder.
  • They boo their first born, at their high school graduation, for not graduating in the top half of the class.
  • They boo at their best friends wedding, because the food isn’t up to their standards.
  • They boo the movie they just watched for not ending the way they wanted it too.

If that’s the case, then by all means, continue to boo the team you “support.” And please, boo this post!

Carlos Figueiredo can usually be found explaining the greatness of Marty Brodeur and David Clarkson over at Speaking of the Devils. If you’re up for upper-division Twitter, he can be found at @SpeakoftheDevs.

SpeakoftheDevs


  • phillyphan

    WOW! I don't know what to say after that 45 minutes of my life. I just wanted to say 3 things. (And I promise to try and keep it short Sir)

    1. I have been Mr. Seats best friend for 30 years and an avid reader of VFCS since it had only a handful of readers. I can also say Seats is raw & full of shit & that's why I love this site but DAMN. It took the new blood a week to turn this into a cock measuring contest.

    2. I've been a DIE HARD Flyers fan since I was old enough to walk. Unlike Mr. Seats, I had season tickets to the Kings for 10 years but fell in love with a different style of hockey. Money is nothing & Phx is proof that even broke teams will function. But when you invest more blood, sweat, & tears into a team then most of the players on the ice, it becomes more then just a game. I'm not even from Philly but I agree with the one city that is NOT in the “MAJORITY” of what people think. It's not disrespectful its more then that. You come to expect a certain level of play & by god I'm not afraid to let them know when they arn't living up to the level they know they could be at.

    3. Lastly. I don't want to sound like a Prick here, BUT, “Yes. Mine was a post. Yours? A comment….think about it.” Sad thing here brother, he is better writer then you so maybe he should be the one making the posts.

    OUT!

    • http://www.viewfrommyseats.com/ Matt Reitz

      Simmer down there Philly Phan. At no point in Carlos' argument did he EVER say that it wasn't OK to boo Santa Claus. I know that's a practice that is near and dear to your heart, so you can continue whenever you please. (please dont go to the “but he was really a bad Santa Claus” argument!)

      And we all know that you're a prick. That's part of your charm. :)

      • phillyphan

        He was a bad Santa but thats another Barolo filled night in of its self. All right maybe I just did what I always do when ever I see anything Devils related.

  • http://speakingofthedevils.com/ SpeakoftheDevs

    Yes. Mine was a post. Yours? A comment….think about it.

    Anyway, you are taking this WAY too personal. NOWHERE did I say you're not allowed to boo. If that's the way you choose to show the team you support that you are dissatisfied with what they're doing, then you are free to do so.

    My post was simply an informative piece. A public service announcement, if you will. Just letting everyone know what the MAJORITY of people think. I'm bringing the message to the people.

    I'm not saying I'm right and you're wrong. But if you look at the comments here, and the comments that were left on my facebook page, and on twitter, you'll see that the majority of people agree with what I wrote.

    If you choose to keep booing, then you are certainly free to do that…nobody is telling you that you CAN'T. Just know that you're in the minority.

  • Kumbaya

    Your article: 699 words. My reply: 672 (733 with “sidenote”). Yet mine was “too much to read”.

    Otherwise, your reply makes even less sense than the original post:

    >>>I have never written a letter to someone who's services I was not happy with saying: Dear X, BOOOO!

    And I have never walked into IKEA with a blue and yellow jersey and face paint. Nor have I gone to a game and screamed out a full complaint letter of my view of the team's lacklustre play. THAT would be sure to fail to get the message across.

    >>> Not quite sure I'd get my message across.

    Really? In any context, I think that one simple syllable is pretty clear of meaning. If you wrote that same letter to the Leafs management, I think they'd understand pretty well that you were dissatisfied.

    Even out of context, I also think that if you walked into IKEA with a half-assembled “BLESFAH” table-lamp-thingy and yelled “Booo”, they'd get the point. And if you persisted with it, somebody would come out to talk to you, so you didn't have to stand there all afternoon with a numbered ticket stub in your hand. In other words, you'd get attention.

    >>> But from what I've seen, heard, and read in these comments so far, I think most people agree with me.

    Perhaps because most of the people who made it all the way through *your* “too much to read” post were the ones who already agreed with you? That's typically the way it works. For the dissenting position, I point you to the thousands of fans who are booing in an arena on any given night.

  • http://speakingofthedevils.com/ SpeakoftheDevs

    That way too much to read.

    In the end, booing is not complaining. COMPLAINING is complaining. Just like I said, I'm all for voicing your displeasure with the way things are going with a team.

    I have never written a letter to someone who's services I was not happy with saying:

    Dear X,

    BOOOO!

    Yours Truly…

    Not quite sure I'd get my message across.

    If someone feels their only means to voice their frustration is to boo, so be it. But from what I've seen, heard, and read in these comments so far, I think most people agree with me. It's pointless and accomplishes nothing.

  • Kumbaya

    What a crock. Allow me to retort.

    So, lemme get this straight: you'll yell, curse, and leave, but you won't BOO. Wow. Words of encouragement? I guess when we enter the arena we should all start by holding hands singing “Kumbaya”.

    Clearly, booing has become for you this sensitive thing that has some special connotation that the average fan doesn't see. For us, it's simply an expression of disappointment — not the sporting equivalent of dropping the C-bomb on your mother-in-law. And I certainly wouldn't characterize it as worse than you yelling 4-letter words from your seat with my son sitting between us.

    I'm not sure you've been paying close attention when the fans start booing their own team. Nobody boos when the team is just having a night of hard luck. If your guys are hauling ass, hitting hard, racing after pucks, and generally building up a sweat, but constantly getting robbed by the post or stymied by a hot goalie, nobody is booing. People boo when the team is dragging their asses, moping around, and generally not demonstrating any form of effort, especially over time. Consistent bone-headed moves, and demonstrating that your head is not in the game, will summon the boo-birds. Doing your best — and showing it — will not.

    In other words, players get booed when they deserve it.

    Sports is a business. We've heard that many times (usually when a team or league is trying to communicate something that is bound to disappoint fans). When a business disappoints me, I do something about it. I express my disappointment. I take the product back and ask for a refund. I complain. But I certainly don't go into a store and give them words of encouragement and ask them to try harder, while I continue to pour money into them.

    Not all those options are available to me in sports (especially if I want to live to your ideal of a “good fan”). At the arena, I've already dumped my money and have no chance of seeing it again, no matter how bad the product I'm about to consume (even after eating a crappy dinner I can still get my money back).

    If a business continues to consistently disappoint me, I stop buying. That's usually a strong message. Few businesses continue to thrive while they suck. Those that do are called Maple Leafs. And those that continue to frequent losers are called suckers, because the business has no incentive to change. ZERO.

    At the extreme other end are Canadiens fans. Fans-in-the-stands and volume of press coverage are inversely proportional based on the competitiveness of the team. And what are the results? What's the greatest number of consecutive seasons you've ever seen a Montreal team be completely non-competitive? Now contrast that with the lovey-dovey, never-an-empty-seat Leafs.

    The problem with withholding your purchase with a sports team (i.e. staying home) is that the fans have learned that the team will just disappear (at least those that are not cultural institutions). Either that, or the owner will hold a move over their heads until the city/government/fans offer up some concession that pads their pockets and artificially keeps them around longer, to further expose you to their crappy product. Either way, the team gets their money. Worst case, you no longer have a team to cheer or boo. Who suffers then? Not the players. Not the owner.

    So I certainly wouldn't question the integrity of someone who hass paid to support their team, then expresses their opinion when criticism is warranted. THAT'S support. Sometimes you use the carrot, sometimes you need the stick.

    People complain because it works. In sports, complaining is booing. It's cathartic, it's one of the only practical options of expressing dissatisfaction available to the average fan, and likely the only method most will ever have to directly communicate with the players on the team. I make no apologies for demanding that a team live up to my expectations, nor for the way I express that to them.

    —————-
    As a sidenote: where I DO think booing sucks is where individuals are singled out on a permanent basis. Toronto, most of you don't even know what Alfredsson even did. It was years ago — let it go. Ottawa, booing opponents like Crosby just because they're GOOD is classless. And in all cases, it's distracting and completely annoying. Just stop.

  • http://twitter.com/Ozzy Jeremy Osborne

    People who boo their own team won't read this. They're too busy coming up with reasons why your team cheated them. And complaining about refs. And how the league screws them on purpose. And how their team “let” your team win, but they'll “get 'em in the playoffs”.

    And so on, and so forth….

    (Oh, and don't forget: how BORING it is to watch your team….)

  • http://twitter.com/bbryon Bryon Beck

    I also yell saucy comments at the TV or if I happen to be in person; but I will only boo the opposing team!

  • http://speakingofthedevils.com/ SpeakoftheDevs

    To me, if I were on the ice and heard my “fans” booing me, my first thought would be “Go on, keep booing, I'm going to go cash my hefty paycheck.”

    Booing doesn't motivate. For me, it would do the complete opposite…but I'm not normal.

  • http://twitter.com/hawknut Ryan Hackett

    I couldn't agree more. It drives me insane when it happens, I've NEVER rained down boos upon the Blackhawks, White Sox, Packers, etc… I choose not to argue with those that do, because I'll mostly just get more aggravated. I've tried booing the booers, but it just blends in with theirs and I look like a jerk-off as well. I just can't see how that helps a team. By the way, I have booed my girlfriend for not being able to cook. Because that's just unacceptable. (I'm kidding people.)

  • http://twitter.com/Hawgs38 Hawgs

    I prefer to reserve my boos for Matt Cooke and Phil Kessel. Can't boo my own team! I have shut-off the game 2x this season, which is something I haven't done in years.

  • http://www.viewfrommyseats.com/ Matt Reitz

    Another excuse for booing: “Im motivating them! They're going to come back and play harder because they know that we're pissed.”

    I'm a bigger fan of muttering in my seat and wondering what the hell is wrong. LOL

  • http://blog.scottpaterson.org/ Scott Paterson

    Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you! I couldn't agree more. I've heard every excuse that you listed, when I've confronted boo-birds. Instead of booing your team, why not start a chant to help give them some drive?! Positive reinforcement works better than negative.

Previous post:

Next post: